Deciding between investing extra funds or using them to repay your mortgage faster is a key financial decision. Both approaches offer benefits, but choosing the right one depends on your specific financial goals, current mortgage interest rate, and risk tolerance.
This guide will help you understand when it makes sense to invest your money for potential growth and when making extra mortgage repayments could be a more advantageous choice.
1. Investing overview
Investing involves allocating money to assets like stocks and bonds with the aim of achieving returns over time. While this approach carries a higher level of risk compared to saving, it also offers the opportunity for greater rewards.
-
Purpose: - Investing is typically focused on long-term financial goals (5+ years away), such as building wealth for retirement.
-
Higher risk to capital: - Investment values can fluctuate significantly which means you may end up with less than you started with. However, with a longer time horizon, there's a greater chance to recover from downturns.
-
Inflation protection: - Investments, particularly in stocks, generally outperform inflation over time, preserving and growing your purchasing power. This is especially important during periods of rising inflation, which can erode the value of savings and debt.
-
Growth: - Over time, investments such as stocks, bonds, and mutual funds have historically provided higher returns than savings accounts, which are more aligned to mortgage rates.
2. Overpaying your mortgage
Overpaying your mortgage involves making additional payments beyond the required monthly amount. This strategy can save you money on interest over the life of the loan and help you become mortgage-free sooner. However, it's essential to weigh the benefits against potential drawbacks and consider how it fits with your broader financial goals.
-
Interest savings: - Overpaying reduces your mortgage balance faster, decreasing the total interest paid over the life of the loan.
-
Quicker mortgage payoff: - By making additional payments, you can shorten your mortgage term, becoming debt-free sooner and redirecting funds toward other financial priorities.
-
Increased equity: - Overpaying builds equity in your home faster. This can make refinancing easier and potentially cheaper, as lenders often offer better rates to borrowers with higher equity.
-
Tax efficiency: - Overpaying your mortgage is tax-efficient because the savings from reduced mortgage interest are not subject to tax. In contrast, growth or income from investments may be taxed, depending on your circumstances.
3. Investing vs. overpaying mortgage comparison
Deciding between investing your money or using it to overpay your mortgage is a common financial dilemma. Both options have distinct advantages and potential drawbacks, depending on your personal goals, risk tolerance, and financial circumstances.
This section provides a side-by-side comparison to help you evaluate the best choice for your situation. Factors such as liquidity, risk, tax implications, and inflation protection are explored to offer a clearer picture of the trade-offs involved.
|
Investing |
Overpay Mortgage |
Risk |
Higher risk
Investment values fluctuate with market conditions and could result in losses, especially in the short term.
|
No risk
Overpayments guarantee savings equivalent to the mortgage interest rate, with no market risk.
|
Taxable gain |
Potentially taxable
Investment growth or income may be subject to income tax and/or capital gains tax. However, this could fall within personal allowances, resulting in no tax liability. Holding investments in tax-efficient wrappers, such as ISAs, shields gains from tax. Investing through pension schemes can be advantageous, offering tax relief on contributions.
|
Tax-efficient
Mortgage interest savings are not subject to tax.
|
Flexibility |
More flexible
Investments allow you to adjust contributions or withdraw funds as needed, depending on your financial goals and market conditions.
|
Not flexible
Overpayments tie up funds in your property, making them difficult to access without refinancing or selling the home.
|
Timeframe |
5 years or more
Investments are better suited for medium to long-term goals. Market fluctuations can lead to short-term losses, but longer time horizons provide more opportunity to recover and grow.
|
No specific timeframe
Overpayments carry no risk to your capital. However, funds are not accessible once paid, and the returns are limited to guaranteed savings equivalent to your mortgage interest rate.
|
Liquidity |
Somewhat liquid
Investments like stocks or ETFs can be sold relatively quickly. However, selling during a market downturn might lock in losses, and withdrawals could incur fees or taxes.
|
Illiquid
Mortgage overpayments are tied to your property, making them inaccessible without refinancing or selling.
|
Inflation protection |
Strong protection
Investments, especially in stocks, tend to grow faster than inflation over the long term, helping maintain or increase your purchasing power.
|
Limited protection
Overpayments do not directly combat inflation. However, during high inflation, holding debt can be advantageous as inflation erodes the real value of the debt, making repayments effectively cheaper over time.
|
Return Potential |
Higher returns
Investments have the potential for much higher long-term returns compared to mortgage interest rates. However, these returns are not guaranteed and come with significant risk, particularly in the short term.
|
Guaranteed return
Overpayments offer a risk-free return equivalent to your mortgage interest rate. While this is lower than potential investment gains, it's a secure and predictable outcome.
|
4. Investment growth vs. cost of debt
Deciding whether to invest or repay debt requires carefully weighing the potential growth of investments against the cost of borrowing. While historical performance provides useful context, it does not guarantee future returns. Investment growth can vary significantly, influenced by market conditions, asset selection, and broader economic trends.
To provide a standardized framework for understanding potential outcomes, the
FCA standardized growth rates
The FCA's prescribed growth rates of 2% (low), 5% (moderate), and 8% (high) are regulatory benchmarks designed for consistent, transparent, and comparable illustrations across financial products. They are not derived from specific market conditions but serve as a helpful guide for evaluating potential investment performance.
are set at 2% (low), 5% (moderate), and 8% (high).
These rates are particularly relevant for long-term investments, such as pensions and ISAs, where compounding has a significant impact over decades. However, they are less representative for short-term investments, where market volatility plays a more prominent role.
Investment growth is inherently unpredictable and depends on market performance. The FCA's growth rates offer a useful perspective on potential outcomes:
-
Low Growth (2%): Reflects conservative investments, like cash or bonds, which typically have lower returns but less risk. A £10,000 investment grows to approximately £10,408 after 5 years.
-
Moderate Growth (5%): Represents a balanced portfolio of equities and bonds or diversified investments. The same £10,000 becomes approximately £12,763 after 5 years.
-
High Growth (8%): Corresponds to higher-risk assets, like equities, which historically have demonstrated stronger long-term growth. It could grow to approximately £14,693 after 5 years.
These scenarios illustrate the power of compounding but emphasize that actual results may vary based on market conditions and other factors.
-
Volatility: Investment growth is not guaranteed. Market dips can reduce the value of your portfolio, particularly in the short term. A long-term horizon is often required to recover and achieve significant growth.
-
Comparison to debt costs: If your investments grow faster than your mortgage interest rate, investing may be more profitable than repaying debt. However, if growth underperforms, reducing debt can provide greater financial benefits by eliminating guaranteed interest costs.
The cost of debt is typically fixed and predictable, making it a reliable benchmark for decision-making. Mortgage interest rates (often 2-4%) provide a guaranteed cost savings if repaid early, while investments carry the risk of underperforming these rates in the short term.
-
Predictability: Paying off mortgage debt offers a guaranteed return equivalent to the interest rate on the loan. This eliminates risk, unlike the uncertainty of investment returns.
-
Certainty of Savings: Overpaying a mortgage with a 3% interest rate is akin to earning a 3% risk-free return, which is especially appealing during times of low investment returns.
Investment growth is uncertain, with potential returns ranging from conservative to aggressive based on market conditions. In contrast, the cost of debt is fixed and predictable. Comparing these two factors can help you determine whether to prioritize investing or reducing debt.
While investments offer the potential for higher returns, they come with inherent risks. Reducing debt, on the other hand, guarantees a return equal to your interest rate. Your decision should align with your financial goals, risk tolerance, and time horizon.
5. Tax treatment on investment growth and income
When considering the advantages of saving versus repaying debt, it's essential to understand the tax treatment on savings interest. The government offers several tax-free allowances on savings, allowing you to earn interest without incurring tax up to specific limits.
If you haven't fully used your Personal Allowance on wages, pensions, or other income, you can apply it to interest on your savings, enabling a portion to be earned tax-free.
In addition to the Personal Allowance, you may qualify for a starting rate for savings, allowing up to £5,000 of tax-free interest if your other income (such as wages or pension) is below a certain threshold:
-
Income under £17,570: - You may be eligible for up to £5,000 in tax-free savings interest. For every £1 of other income above your Personal Allowance, your starting rate for savings decreases by £1.
-
Income over £17,570: - You're not eligible for the starting rate for savings.
Example: - If you earn £16,000 from wages and have £200 in savings interest, your £12,570 Personal Allowance covers the first £12,570 of your wages. The remaining £3,430 reduces your starting rate for savings from £5,000 to £1,570. This leaves your £200 interest tax-free.
Beyond the starting rate, you may also benefit from the Personal Savings Allowance, allowing up to £1,000 of tax-free interest based on your tax band.
Income Tax Band |
Personal Savings Allowance |
Basic rate |
£1,000 |
Higher rate |
£500 |
Additional rate |
£0 |
For additional tax-free savings, ISAs offer a tax-efficient option. Interest and income generated within ISAs are exempt from tax, making ISAs a valuable choice if you’ve used up your Personal Savings Allowance and starting rate for savings.
ISA Type |
Annual Allowance |
Overall ISA allowance |
£20,000 |
Lifetime ISA (LISA) |
£4,000 (counts towards overall allowance) |
Junior ISA (JISA) |
£9,000 (per child) |
Note: You can split your allowance between a stocks and shares Isa, cash Isa, lifetime Isa and innovative finance Isa. For more informaiton on ISA allowances
read our guide.
6. Tax treatment on debt repayments
Unlike savings interest, repaying debt is not subject to tax making the effective return on overpaying debt equal to the loan's APR (Annual Percentage Rate).
When your savings interest is taxed, repaying high-interest debt can offer a greater financial advantage. By reducing debt, you effectively gain a “return” equal to the debt's interest rate, which is tax-free. This makes debt repayment especially appealing when your savings are taxed.
7. Save vs ovepay mortgage projections
Try our simple to use calculator to calculate the growth of a savings account and project investment growth for high, medium and low risk portfolios.
For greater functionality try our stand-alone
save or repay mortgage
calculator.
8. Other factors to consider
While this model offers insights into the potential outcomes of saving versus mortgage repayment, it's important to understand its limitations. Real-world factors and individual financial situations can influence outcomes in ways the model may not fully capture. Here are some of the key limitations and other considerations to keep in mind.
-
Investment growth rate: - The model assumes q fixed savings interest rates. However, real savings rates may vary due to economic shifts, central bank policies, or inflation, impacting actual returns on savings.
-
New mortgage fixed rate: - Changes in fixed-rate mortgages at renewal points aren't always captured by the model. Economic conditions could impact the rate offered when your fixed period ends, influencing whether saving or repaying is more advantageous.
-
SVR changes: - Standard Variable Rates (SVR) can change over time, often influenced by macroeconomic conditions. The model does not reflect these shifts, so any variable rate mortgage scenarios may vary from actual results.
-
Tax implications: - The model estimates gross returns but does not always factor in specific tax impacts on savings, which can reduce net returns and affect the balance between saving and mortgage repayment benefits.
-
Economic and market variability: - Economic downturns or inflation could impact both mortgage rates and savings yields. In tougher times, access to savings may be critical, which isn't reflected in the model's assumptions.
-
Behavioral factors: - The model does not account for personal financial habits or changes in spending behavior, which can influence the effectiveness of a savings or repayment plan over time.
-
Unforeseen financial changes: - Life events like job loss, health issues, or major unexpected expenses are not reflected in the model but can greatly impact financial priorities and the feasibility of either saving or mortgage repayment.
9. Alternative options to consider
Beyond traditional saving or mortgage repayment, diversifying into other asset classes may provide additional growth opportunities and risk management. Here are some alternative options that may align with broader financial goals.
-
Savings: - Bonds are generally considered a lower-risk investment compared to equities and can provide a fixed income over time. They are an option for those seeking steady returns without the volatility of the stock market, though returns are often lower than stocks.
-
Premium bonds: - Commodities like gold, silver, and oil offer a hedge against inflation and can provide a safe haven in times of economic uncertainty. While they can add diversification, commodity prices can be volatile and may not suit all risk profiles.
-
Investment property: - For those interested in real estate without the commitment of physical property ownership, REITs allow investment in real estate assets and may generate income through dividends. This can provide exposure to the real estate market with more liquidity than direct property investment.
-
Pension contributions: - Making contributions to a pension provides tax advantages and is an effective way to build long-term financial security, especially for retirement. Pensions grow tax-free and often come with employer-matching contributions, making them a valuable asset class.
10. Checklist
Before deciding between investing and repaying debt, use this checklist to evaluate your financial priorities. Key areas like maintaining an emergency fund, managing high-interest debt, and setting clear financial goals play essential roles in determining the best approach.
-
Emergency fund: - Ensure you have 3 to 6 months' worth of living expenses in an emergency fund. This fund provides stability during unforeseen events or income disruptions, acting as a financial cushion so that you don't need to rely on high-interest loans or credit cards in times of need.
-
High-interest debt repayment: - High-interest debt, such as credit cards or personal loans, can significantly reduce your financial flexibility. Paying down these debts should be a priority since the interest accrued is often higher than returns from low-risk savings.
-
Short-term goals (0-5 years): - Make sure you have a savings plan for upcoming short-term goals, such as vacations or home improvements. Remember, once an overpayment is made toward debt, those funds are not long accessible.
-
Long-term financial goals (5+ years): - Ensure you have a clear plan to save for long-term financial objectives, such as retirement. Keep in mind that mortgage overpayments are typically irreversible, so consider whether investing might better support your overall financial flexibility.
-
Interest rate comparison: - Compare your mortgage rate with potential returns from other asset classes. If your mortgage rate is relatively high, overpaying may yield better results than low-yield savings accounts, however, investments in diversified assets could potentially provide greater returns if you're comfortable with associated risks.